Six Shootouts, Six Defeats: Princeton’s Season Ends the Way It Lived as UConn Reach the Final Four
Princeton’s season ended the way it lived: with a shootout loss. The sixth one.
No. 5 Princeton lost 1-0 to No. 4 UConn in the NCAA quarter-finals on Sunday, at Nancy Stevens Field in Storrs, after 75 scoreless minutes and a shootout that UConn won 4-2. Charlotte Ritter converted the winner. The Tigers go home at 14-6, and the numbers tell the whole story. They went 14-0 in games that didn’t go to a shootout. They went 0-6 in the ones that did.
Princeton are the only team in Division I unbeaten in games that didn’t reach a shootout. That’s no consolation when the shootout is what keeps ending your season. Their six shootout defeats are four more than the next-most by any Division I team this year.
And it wasn’t just this game. The shootouts cost Princeton everything. They lost the Ivy League title to Harvard in a shootout. They lost the Ivy League tournament title to Yale in a shootout. Now they’ve lost a return trip to the NCAA Final Four in a shootout, a year after reaching the national final. It was also the second time this season UConn have beaten them in a shootout on their own pitch, after doing the same back in September.
Seventy-five minutes, no goal, and UConn playing for the shootout
For 75 minutes, neither side could find the net. That’s 60 minutes of regulation and one 15-minute overtime period, under the new Division I overtime rule this season: a single 15-minute period, 11 against 11, then straight to a shootout. Princeton outshot UConn 7-3 and had the better of possession in the second half and overtime. But UConn knew exactly what they were doing in the extra period. Their plan was to get to the shootout, and they lifted the ball the length of the field on every possession in overtime, gave it straight back to Princeton, and dropped back to defend.
Freshman goalkeeper Josie Bianco, in only her second start, made three saves and didn’t allow a goal in 135 minutes of NCAA tournament hockey. For the season, Princeton allowed just 14 goals, and only four of those came in the run of play. This was a team that barely conceded. It just couldn’t win a shootout.
The shootout itself followed the season’s script. Caitlin Thompson scored on Princeton’s first attempt, after Bianco had made a save on UConn. Hope Delaney scored too. Then four straight UConn conversions, from Lene Reiche, Lucy Zich, Olivia McKenna and Ritter, and it was over. UConn goalkeeper Natalie McKenna, the Big East Goalkeeper of the Year, made four saves in regulation and two more stops in the shootout, denying Anna Faulstich and Saylor Milone.
UConn go to Louisville, Princeton wonder what might have been
UConn are 17-2 and through to the Final Four for the first time since winning the national championship in 2017. They face top seed Northwestern in the semi-finals on Friday 20 November at Trager Stadium in Louisville, 2:30pm ET, 12:30am PKT on Saturday. The final is on Sunday 22 November at 1pm ET, 11:00pm PKT.
Princeton are left with the cruellest stat line in college hockey this year. Fourteen wins, six defeats, and every single defeat came the same way. A team that good doesn’t lose six games in a season. Unless every one of them is decided from the spot.
